
The topic of today's post revolves around "
high dynamic range photography" or "
HDR." I'm a fan of
HDR in principle, though I was
initially quite
disappointed in most folks use of the technique. In short, I don't care for
HDR imagery that looks like
HDR imagery!
To my eyes any
HDR image that looks at first glance like an
HDR image is just wrong; a veritable crime against nature, a form of visual heresy where the photos take on a decidedly alien aura that is simply not natural. Much of this is due to heavy-handed technique and can be avoided, but like so many of the PS tools where there is ample room for interpretation, I suppose there will always be those that insist on pushing things to the edge, and over, in search of their own personal brand of photographic enlightenment. Which is fine, I suppose. Nobody said I had to like it.
Still, I do hope this overindulgence will prove to be nothing more that a passing fad and that these otherwise excellent photographers will eventually come to their senses and begin using the software in a more sensible manner. One only needs to look through the
HDR offerings on photo sharing sites such as "
pbase" and "
flikr" to see what I mean. You'll find some nice images that are tastefully rendered, true, but you will also find the bizarre aura that
accompanies those that aren't as well managed. Gack! To my eyes, anyways, many of these are decidedly overworked.
This alien aura made me very leery of the process at first. For a time it was so
prevalent in HDR images that I thought it was an unavoidable by-product of the process, like so much
manure in the stockyard. Eventually, though, I saw enough good of the technique to spring for the software. (Of course, if you use CS2 you get this built in, but I am still using CS.)
I quickly found that using the software to blend the images is not hard, but learning how to get images that looked sensible takes time. Several interesting things happen in the image merging and tone mapping process that I don't begin to understand, and I will probably have to tinker with the technique for while before I am
truly comfortable, but it is fun.
The image presented here represents one of my more worthwhile attempts. I still find the saturation a bit garish, but otherwise it looks too flat. Colors seem to get heated up and overcook really fast, especially the reds and greens, and keeping these looking more or less natural is a real concern.